What's new
Forums
Members
Resources
Whopper Club
Politics
Pics
Videos
Fishing Reports
Classifieds
Log in
Register
What's new
Search
Members
Resources
Whopper Club
Politics
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Forums
Hunting
Big Game Hunting
Moose
Deer have direct role in death of Minnesota moose
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Reply to thread
Message
<blockquote data-quote="guywhofishes" data-source="post: 197063" data-attributes="member: 337"><p>That leaves hunting.</p><p> “If I were king of the world,” said Moore of the Grand Portage Band, “I would aggressively hunt deer to the point where the population declines.”</p><p> But he gets resistance to that, he said, and so does the DNR.</p><p> “I have tribal members who are furious with me for trying to manage the deer population,” Moore said.</p><p> ‘I can’t hunt them’</p><p> This year for the first time the DNR took steps to manage deer with moose in mind. Deer hunting “permit areas” in the far northeast corner of the state have been reconfigured to more clearly designate moose regions and reduce deer numbers there relative to other parts of the state.</p><p> But biologists argue that the state could do more for the sake of the moose.</p><p> For instance, the deer population goals around the perimeter of moose country are considerably higher than inside, and deer are known to migrate for many miles. And within the deer permit area around Grand Marais and up to Canada, current hunting rules are designed to increase deer numbers slightly.</p><p> “No, I don’t think a harvest strategy designed to increase deer numbers is helpful for moose,” said Mike Schrage, wildlife biologist for the Fond du Lac Band of Chippewa. That permit area, he said, “contains some of our best remaining moose country.”</p><p> Steve Merchant, the DNR’s wildlife populations manager, said that if protecting moose were the only consideration, cutting deer numbers would make sense. But human politics influence the agency’s decisions, too, he said. There are, after all, far more deer hunters than moose in that part of the state — some 11,000 bought permits to hunt there last fall.</p><p> “Some deer hunters don’t think we should worry about moose,” Merchant said. That’s not the majority, he added, but there are some who think “ ‘why should we care for moose, I can’t hunt them,” he said.</p><p> Bowe, the taxidermist from Duluth, had an even more fatalistic perspective.</p><p> “If you believe in the theory of global warming, moose are at their southern range and won’t be able to survive anyway,” he said. “That’s my take on it.”</p><p> Craig Engwall, executive director of the Minnesota Deer Hunters Association, said that it could make sense to lower deer numbers in moose range, but only if there is clear science to support the benefit and a transparent public process that goes with the decisions. In the meantime, the association is part of a $3 million project to improve moose habitat through logging to encourage patches of new forest growth and better forage.</p><p> What about the snails?</p><p> At the University of Minnesota, scientists are studying a third species that could change the equation: snails.</p><p> Deer and moose have to eat “tens of thousands of snails to be infected,” said Tiffany Wolf, an animal epidemiologist at the U’s School of Veterinary Medicine, who is working with the Grand Portage band to solve the puzzle. She wants to do genetic research that could reveal which snails end up in moose and deer feces and could help break the cycle of transmission.</p><p> Because tamping down on the number of snails, she said, would be a much easier sell than getting rid of the deer.</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="guywhofishes, post: 197063, member: 337"] That leaves hunting. “If I were king of the world,” said Moore of the Grand Portage Band, “I would aggressively hunt deer to the point where the population declines.” But he gets resistance to that, he said, and so does the DNR. “I have tribal members who are furious with me for trying to manage the deer population,” Moore said. ‘I can’t hunt them’ This year for the first time the DNR took steps to manage deer with moose in mind. Deer hunting “permit areas” in the far northeast corner of the state have been reconfigured to more clearly designate moose regions and reduce deer numbers there relative to other parts of the state. But biologists argue that the state could do more for the sake of the moose. For instance, the deer population goals around the perimeter of moose country are considerably higher than inside, and deer are known to migrate for many miles. And within the deer permit area around Grand Marais and up to Canada, current hunting rules are designed to increase deer numbers slightly. “No, I don’t think a harvest strategy designed to increase deer numbers is helpful for moose,” said Mike Schrage, wildlife biologist for the Fond du Lac Band of Chippewa. That permit area, he said, “contains some of our best remaining moose country.” Steve Merchant, the DNR’s wildlife populations manager, said that if protecting moose were the only consideration, cutting deer numbers would make sense. But human politics influence the agency’s decisions, too, he said. There are, after all, far more deer hunters than moose in that part of the state — some 11,000 bought permits to hunt there last fall. “Some deer hunters don’t think we should worry about moose,” Merchant said. That’s not the majority, he added, but there are some who think “ ‘why should we care for moose, I can’t hunt them,” he said. Bowe, the taxidermist from Duluth, had an even more fatalistic perspective. “If you believe in the theory of global warming, moose are at their southern range and won’t be able to survive anyway,” he said. “That’s my take on it.” Craig Engwall, executive director of the Minnesota Deer Hunters Association, said that it could make sense to lower deer numbers in moose range, but only if there is clear science to support the benefit and a transparent public process that goes with the decisions. In the meantime, the association is part of a $3 million project to improve moose habitat through logging to encourage patches of new forest growth and better forage. What about the snails? At the University of Minnesota, scientists are studying a third species that could change the equation: snails. Deer and moose have to eat “tens of thousands of snails to be infected,” said Tiffany Wolf, an animal epidemiologist at the U’s School of Veterinary Medicine, who is working with the Grand Portage band to solve the puzzle. She wants to do genetic research that could reveal which snails end up in moose and deer feces and could help break the cycle of transmission. Because tamping down on the number of snails, she said, would be a much easier sell than getting rid of the deer. [/QUOTE]
Verification
What is the most common fish caught on this site?
Post reply
Recent Posts
P
Outdoor photo request
Latest: PrairieGhost
7 minutes ago
Remote camera options
Latest: Lycanthrope
13 minutes ago
T
Batten down the hatches!
Latest: Traxion
14 minutes ago
F
Property Tax Credit
Latest: Fester
20 minutes ago
Beef prices going up????
Latest: Davy Crockett
Today at 10:27 AM
Accuphy Ping Live Sonar
Latest: Shockwave
Today at 9:10 AM
OAHE Ice 25/26
Latest: Kurtr
Today at 8:25 AM
Look at the size of that deer
Latest: Lycanthrope
Today at 7:11 AM
NFL News (Vikings)
Latest: Jiffy
Today at 6:27 AM
Wolf Hunting?
Latest: SDMF
Yesterday at 11:32 PM
Satellite Internet
Latest: grantfurness
Yesterday at 10:11 PM
R
Any ice reports?
Latest: riverview
Yesterday at 9:25 PM
Weather 6/20/25
Latest: Jiffy
Yesterday at 7:57 PM
Alkaline lake ice conditions?
Latest: NDSportsman
Yesterday at 2:55 PM
N
ION gen2 8"
Latest: ndrivrrat
Tuesday at 5:43 PM
Four legged tax deduction
Latest: luvcatchingbass
Tuesday at 4:51 PM
I HATE coyotes!!!!
Latest: luvcatchingbass
Tuesday at 4:43 PM
Wolves at J Clark Sawyer
Latest: Davy Crockett
Tuesday at 11:08 AM
W
Which one you did this?
Latest: walleyeman_1875
Monday at 12:17 PM
S
Anyone snare rabbits?
Latest: snow2
Sunday at 9:46 AM
Deer speeds.
Latest: Kurtr
Sunday at 9:08 AM
6.5 Creedmore
Latest: Jiffy
Sunday at 8:25 AM
N
Crazy Fingers
Latest: NodakBob
Saturday at 2:39 PM
Friends of NDA
Forums
Hunting
Big Game Hunting
Moose
Deer have direct role in death of Minnesota moose
Top
Bottom