Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Meelosh" data-source="post: 227446" data-attributes="member: 3011">The one tag he would be giving up is the tag literally every single person can buy. That is the failed logic in your thinking. With what everyone in this one tag scenario is proposing, is the all the bow tags, the muzzleloader tags and the rifle tags into one pool. Let's say that is 80,000 tags for example. The problem is, each weapon has different success. However, the G&amp;F will have to treat each one as a rifle tag because it the most impact in the population. So, to compensate for that, they can't allocate the 80,000 tags they would now. They would only be able to allocate, say 60,000 or so. So overall, less opportunity for everyone. Sure some guys will treat it as only a bow tag or only a muzzleloader but the G and F can't rely on people to self police. How on earth can you guys see that as a win? Is that seriously what you consider fair? This has been explained several times over. Those that are still advocating for it aren't interested in getting it right. You just want to be right and there is a huge difference.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Meelosh, post: 227446, member: 3011"] The one tag he would be giving up is the tag literally every single person can buy. That is the failed logic in your thinking. With what everyone in this one tag scenario is proposing, is the all the bow tags, the muzzleloader tags and the rifle tags into one pool. Let's say that is 80,000 tags for example. The problem is, each weapon has different success. However, the G&F will have to treat each one as a rifle tag because it the most impact in the population. So, to compensate for that, they can't allocate the 80,000 tags they would now. They would only be able to allocate, say 60,000 or so. So overall, less opportunity for everyone. Sure some guys will treat it as only a bow tag or only a muzzleloader but the G and F can't rely on people to self police. How on earth can you guys see that as a win? Is that seriously what you consider fair? This has been explained several times over. Those that are still advocating for it aren't interested in getting it right. You just want to be right and there is a huge difference. [/QUOTE]

Verification

What is the most common fish caught on this site?

Reply to thread

Recent Posts

Friends of NDA