My dad and his buddies used to use them all the time while fishing with tipups. I'm pretty sure I lost more fish and I actually caught with them. I prefer to use the quick strike style myself.I don’t see anything about those big Norwegian pike hooks. Does anyone actually use those?
It's takes lots of practice to master the smelt hook but once you do it is designed to not be able to be spit out. I do use a stinger with a jig set up on my self setting tip ups though it's much easier when you are just using minnows compared to using a 6+ inch sucker, smelt, or blue herring as bait then it's the smelt hook.My dad and his buddies used to use them all the time while fishing with tipups. I'm pretty sure I lost more fish and I actually caught with them. I prefer to use the quick strike style myself.