What's new
Forums
Members
Resources
Whopper Club
Politics
Pics
Videos
Fishing Reports
Classifieds
Log in
Register
What's new
Search
Members
Resources
Whopper Club
Politics
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Forums
Hunting
Big Game Hunting
Deer
Targeted Removal
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Reply to thread
Message
<blockquote data-quote="deleted user" data-source="post: 391374" data-attributes="member: 1778"><p>Well, the deer can't get in or out. They are in a preserve that provides food, water, shelter, and protection. Predators are voraciously controlled so there is little stress. Only certain animals of a certain size are allowed to be harvested. Even if they catch CWD, they'll live to be 4 years old and be big enough through selective breeding for large antlers. They are oftentimes as "wild" as Fritz's elk, so not indicative of how any population of wild animals can be managed. Lunk we can complain until we're blue in the face that deer hunting has gotten harder, but until there is a way to put more trees and grass on the landscape, nature is going to take the population down from time to time. We still have a lot of opportunities to take nice animals in the state. EHD, 8 months of winter, and lack of habitat isn't the game and fish's fault. Tell me your thoughts on what they should do. I am 100% for squeezing the vice on NDGF if they blatantly push their own ethics into regs. My stance is a cornpile has a negligible effect on the spread, but like ANS they do what is within their power to slow it. I won't defend their CWD push, but if you ask me not allowing baiting in certain counties is pretty low on my radar as far as things to be worried about (ND hunting wise). I can still grow a patch of corn and be perfectly legal. In essence, it would take a big amount of money and a change of mindset for ND to turn around and we will still probably never be a trophy destination. We all know that mid winter this place is a moonscape and land owner tendencies have changed compared to what it was 20 years ago.</p><p></p><p> The thing is Lunk, we don't all want the same thing. Fritz and the Farm bureau want the game and fish department gone. Read their policies and ask why any outdoorsman would consider them an ally. They don't want you on the dirt roads if you aren't farming or ranching. I have a FB neighbor that gives me problems because my land isn't in production even though noxious weeds are controlled. He just thinks that since its purely recreational he can tell me what to do and that is their mindset. They say they're on the hunter's side, but that's only now while its convenient. Talk to Daryl L, Gabe and his son, or the CWD FB page. The conversation will go from "it's about baiting, its about kids/handicapped opportunities, it's about nutrition, it's about government overreach, it's about landowner rights". In that order. Every time. They don't have a specific problem, or solution. It's just game and fish = bad, farmers and ranchers need to be in charge. NDFB have a plan of "death by a thousand paper cuts" through legislation until hunters and fishermen have no more interest in ND outdoors and they have control. They will control everything; tag allocation, access, you name it and I 100% guarantee you will see this coming down the pipe. In fact, I will bookmark this post and bring it back at the next biennium. Once we set the precedent that game and fish laws are legislated via emotional outrage, we will circle the drain.</p><p></p><p>Have you heard the term "useful idiots"? Where a cause is propagandized and the masses get so fired up about a single detail, they end up doing the dirty work for those behind the scenes to their own detriment? Strong case with CWD crowd.</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="deleted user, post: 391374, member: 1778"] Well, the deer can't get in or out. They are in a preserve that provides food, water, shelter, and protection. Predators are voraciously controlled so there is little stress. Only certain animals of a certain size are allowed to be harvested. Even if they catch CWD, they'll live to be 4 years old and be big enough through selective breeding for large antlers. They are oftentimes as "wild" as Fritz's elk, so not indicative of how any population of wild animals can be managed. Lunk we can complain until we're blue in the face that deer hunting has gotten harder, but until there is a way to put more trees and grass on the landscape, nature is going to take the population down from time to time. We still have a lot of opportunities to take nice animals in the state. EHD, 8 months of winter, and lack of habitat isn't the game and fish's fault. Tell me your thoughts on what they should do. I am 100% for squeezing the vice on NDGF if they blatantly push their own ethics into regs. My stance is a cornpile has a negligible effect on the spread, but like ANS they do what is within their power to slow it. I won't defend their CWD push, but if you ask me not allowing baiting in certain counties is pretty low on my radar as far as things to be worried about (ND hunting wise). I can still grow a patch of corn and be perfectly legal. In essence, it would take a big amount of money and a change of mindset for ND to turn around and we will still probably never be a trophy destination. We all know that mid winter this place is a moonscape and land owner tendencies have changed compared to what it was 20 years ago. The thing is Lunk, we don't all want the same thing. Fritz and the Farm bureau want the game and fish department gone. Read their policies and ask why any outdoorsman would consider them an ally. They don't want you on the dirt roads if you aren't farming or ranching. I have a FB neighbor that gives me problems because my land isn't in production even though noxious weeds are controlled. He just thinks that since its purely recreational he can tell me what to do and that is their mindset. They say they're on the hunter's side, but that's only now while its convenient. Talk to Daryl L, Gabe and his son, or the CWD FB page. The conversation will go from "it's about baiting, its about kids/handicapped opportunities, it's about nutrition, it's about government overreach, it's about landowner rights". In that order. Every time. They don't have a specific problem, or solution. It's just game and fish = bad, farmers and ranchers need to be in charge. NDFB have a plan of "death by a thousand paper cuts" through legislation until hunters and fishermen have no more interest in ND outdoors and they have control. They will control everything; tag allocation, access, you name it and I 100% guarantee you will see this coming down the pipe. In fact, I will bookmark this post and bring it back at the next biennium. Once we set the precedent that game and fish laws are legislated via emotional outrage, we will circle the drain. Have you heard the term "useful idiots"? Where a cause is propagandized and the masses get so fired up about a single detail, they end up doing the dirty work for those behind the scenes to their own detriment? Strong case with CWD crowd. [/QUOTE]
Verification
What is the most common fish caught on this site?
Post reply
Recent Posts
Wind
Latest: Duckslayer100
7 minutes ago
N
Any Birders here?
Latest: NodakBob
10 minutes ago
R
2026 Deer Season Set
Latest: Ruttin
16 minutes ago
Newtown Aim May 9 2026
Latest: Kurtr
Today at 2:12 PM
T
Spring has sprung-
Latest: thriller1
Today at 2:04 PM
Spam phone calls!
Latest: NDSportsman
Today at 1:34 PM
I
Drew my ND moose tag!
Latest: Iwhackwheat
Today at 12:16 PM
ND Constitutional measure
Latest: NDSportsman
Today at 10:12 AM
Battery fires
Latest: wslayer
Today at 9:15 AM
M
Steak YT (Cowboy Rollins)
Latest: measure-it
Today at 8:04 AM
"Pocket" Handguns YT
Latest: svnmag
Yesterday at 8:00 PM
Elec Golf Cart Conversion kit
Latest: Hamm's
Yesterday at 7:55 PM
Which one of you did this?
Latest: svnmag
Yesterday at 7:54 PM
SD Elk
Latest: Kurtr
Yesterday at 9:53 AM
For sale. 12 boxes of...
Latest: bucksnbears
Sunday at 7:00 PM
Do you have a dock/boatlift ?
Latest: Davy Crockett
Sunday at 6:27 PM
T
NFL News (Vikings)
Latest: thriller1
Sunday at 6:50 AM
What are you listening to these days?
Latest: svnmag
Saturday at 11:50 PM
Found a Round
Latest: svnmag
Saturday at 7:52 PM
RIP Ted Turner
Latest: Rowdie
Saturday at 7:36 PM
Put in for the extra Cow
Latest: wslayer
Saturday at 5:56 PM
Friends of NDA
Forums
Hunting
Big Game Hunting
Deer
Targeted Removal
Top
Bottom