Damn right; especially with soft baits. Usually the lighter the tick the bigger the fish. My best bass (8 1/2) on a worm struck like a gnat. I nearly lost the rod when I slammed home. Good lesson! Usually it's easy to judge quality with a hard bait with some exceptions. If you're throwing a spinnerbait or crank (not jerkbait) and it suddenly feels as if your line is cut, get your line tight fast, slam it home and be ready. In fact, anytime your line feels suddenly slack there's a good chance it's a slug IME.
- - - Updated - - -
I couldn't decide how far to break it down. I almost included a "strike" option.