I had the ariat square toe pull ons and they were probably the best I had as far as comfort, I bought them 4 years back and wore them 2 years the leather on the toe wore out but the rest of the boot held up good. After that I bought the double h black ice and they were decent not as comfy as the ariats but a nice boot. In November I bought a pair of twisted X with the extra wide toe, and they have been really good probably second place behind the ariats. I have worn rockies before and thought they were garbage, compared to the ariats. Also I had dr. maartens and they were a decent boot but the leather wore out fast and they were really heavy, I know a few guys that run the lace up redwings and like them, but I have always worn the cowboy boot style.