9 of us have ions of all generations and all are going strong with no issues. Blades hate sand and reopen holes on the houses great. Used a strikmaster with chipper flighting up on Lake of the woods and was impressed with it. Funny thing is they all drill holes. Pick the one that fits your budget and go fishing. Don't think you will go wrong with either 1. If your buddies have 1 or the other get that so you can just grab an extra battery in case you need it on a long day.