Will it kill a deer? Yep! Is it the best option? Nope! Frontal shots regardless of weapon used, normally result in the gut cavity being perforated and many times the bullet or arrow ends up in the hams. Field dressing gut shot deer is distasteful to say the least and marinading the meat in gut contents isn't a good way to ensure top quality table fare either. It's a mess I avoid at all costs. I wait for a shot that doesn't involve anything behind the diaphragm. If someone decides to take a frontal shot, I rarely lend a hand during the field dressing. I figure if you "Have" to have that deer so bad you take a frontal shot on your own, you should also "Have" to deal with the consequences of taking that shot.........on your own.