I'm agreeing with everyone above. I don't think you can really go with todays bows so go with whatever feels the most comfortable to you. When I decided to upgrade a few years ago I was between a Hoyt, Bowtech and Mathews that where all in my price range. My deciding factor was shooting them next to each other with no sites and the Mathews stacked all the arrows the Scheels guy had, after that he believed me when I said I used to shoot no sites.
- - - Updated - - -
I'm agreeing with everyone above. I don't think you can really go wrong with todays bows so go with whatever feels the most comfortable to you. When I decided to upgrade a few years ago I was between a Hoyt, Bowtech and Mathews that where all in my price range. My deciding factor was shooting them next to each other with no sites and the Mathews stacked all the arrows the Scheels guy had, after that he believed me when I said I used to shoot no sites.