Would you want a 'Product Reviews' section on NDA?

[Vollmer]

So I am toying around with the idea of building in a 'reviews' system.
This will allow members to post reviews of products that they have purchased and/or have knowledge of.

Buy a new gps/sonar unit, and let people know what you think of it.

I realize that this can be done in the forums, but I would prefer to build a system for it. Something more professional, and user friendly.

So, would you want this? Would you use this? Thanks for any feedback.

 

[BP338]

If there's room I say put it in there. I'd use it.

 

[Kickemup]

I think it is a great idea.

 

[raider]

good idea, and to keep it out of the forum section to make it available for all to see without having to search for it would be nice, even if the last post was a few months ago... great way to help out the impulse shopper, or guy that needs a new graph for the weekend and doesn't have time to wait 3 days for a good enough review sample to help him make a decision... i like...

 

[NDwalleyes]

Vollmer, great idea. We have had several great discussions on products over the years, most were covered several times. May be best to create categories such as, hunting clothing, footwear, optics, fishing rods, ....etc.

I think most guys are (brutally) honest about products they have tried. You could also offer a section of "NDA Approved/Recommended Products.

 

[Kasey]

I always like to hear from others about their experience with products , and happy to share . Yeah I think it would be a great idea.

 

[deleted_account]

Vollmer, great idea. We have had several great discussions on products over the years, most were covered several times. May be best to create categories such as, hunting clothing, footwear, optics, fishing rods, ....etc.

I think most guys are (brutally) honest about products they have tried. You could also offer a section of "NDA Approved/Recommended Products.

I like this idea very much especially the categories part. Also, like someone else mentioned, even if the thing sits idle for a month or 2 (though i doubt it will) its still worth having a section to hash these things out.

Man, if we can get Tim over here, he'd be all over the product review section.... even though he still wouldnt actually end up buying anything....

 

[dust in the wind]

I like the idea.

 

[johnr]

Would be crazy not toThumbs Up

 

[vikingsfan97]

I like the idea as long as the reviews are detailed not just this is a bad product don't use it

 

[dust in the wind]

I like the idea as long as the reviews are detailed not just this is a bad product don't use it

That's where tools such as the reputation and/or the ignore function can come in handy.

 

[SDMF]

Great idea as long as no one argues.....................Sarcasm button, we need a sarcasm button. (grin)

 

[freiday31]

would be an awesome feature.

 

[Vollmer]

Great idea as long as no one argues.....................Sarcasm button, we need a sarcasm button. (grin)

Ok ok ... Ill have it in this week

 

[Fishing Forever]

That would be nice.

 

[martinslanding]

I would not disagree with this...

 

[Norske]

Whenever someone asks about a product on another popular fishing website, those who bought it rave, and those who didn't slam it. It's hard to admit that pricey thing you bought isn't as good as you thought it would be.

 

[Fisherman25]

Yes, good idea.